Shaniel Done
ENGL 101 – 0768
Dr. Vasileiou
Essay # 1
10/01/12
What is a real Utopia?
Every
improvement made in the history of the human race take us one step closer to
what we call a Utopia, a place where everything is perfect, I mean nothing and
again nothing goes wrong, where diseases are a myth and everyone is equal, we
are moving away from a dystopia, a place with many mistakes and imperfections,
but this does not mean we are there yet.
In this essay I will demonstrate how the world presented in the movie
Gattaca is not a Utopia but a Dystopia by providing evidence and details of
skill discrimination and others that support my point of view from the movie Gattaca,
the views Annas offers in his essay, and examples from human history as well as
the present.
In the movie Gattaca from the beginning to the end of the
movie one topic is always present and that topic is skills discrimination, is
more than clear that the new ideal human, the genetically engineered human are
in the top of the pyramid and the “normal” human are beneath. When a society or
community separate two groups and call them different, that’s when one of the
groups will feel discriminated by the other and the time will lead to confrontations,
fights, and unhappiness, finally both groups will see the other as the
enemy. In this movie being normal is not
a fortune, being normal means that you are not going to be eligible for many
type of work, you will be limited. Now
is this a Utopia? –no—this is not something that I will call perfect, African
American versus the white man, Dominican versus Haitian, poor people versus the
rich… this fights goes on and on it doesn’t stop, this is something that is
keeping us away from a Utopia dream.
George j. Annas mention the novella “Animal farm” by
George Orwell where “all animal are equal, but some are more equal than others”
George j. Annas is trying to demonstrate how the perfect human will see
themselves as more equal than the other and how better does not mean
perfect. George j. annas essay shows all
the negative sides of the movie Gattaca it explain that such future is not a
utopia and that to become one it most have several changes. For example is all humans were able to live
more than nineties years or so than wont we have problem with overpopulation or
will all the natural reassures be enough for such amount of people? Of course the eradication of terminal
illnesses, the environmentally safe means of transportation the advances in technology
etc… are really good thing for the word and we want to get there, but all of
that does not mean we are in utopia yet, no into all problems are solved.
In Gattaca Vincent face many struggles and he find
himself skill discriminated because he is normal, his goal is to travel to
space, but for been normal the closer to a spaceship he gets is to clean the
office of the company. In his world you
have a job according to your genes, skill and if you are a genetically
engineered human, the better you are the better your job. This clearly demonstrates the discrimination
over normal humans and how their skills are what represent each one.
Lest
think about phones, almost every year about five to six new phones are made and
each more and more expensive, people buy them because “they are better than the
old ones”, but is this really truth.
Well many people prefer the old because the battery holds more, are more
indestructible for the material is made, are less expensive and does its
job. Now the new phone does not look so
better, this is a example from today and also a metaphor to compare a
genetically engineered human and the normal human in terms of skills for
example in Gattaca Anton the younger brother the perfect one “the new”
surpasses his older brother in many aspects including in the game call
“chicken” where they swing as far as they can and the first to give up and
swing back to the shore is the loser, Anton used to win, hi was good at that
game but Vincent the normal brother he finally prove that he is not imperfect
by defeating his younger brother twice.
Is more than clear that the word
presented in Gattaca is not a utopia because still have negatives sides and a
utopia for all we know shouldn’t have such problems or mistakes it should be
perfect in every sense of the word, Gattaca is a better dystopia than today for
all the advances in the fields of technology, medicine et.. but upon anything
the human survival.